Great story or bad art? You can't get one without the other in Superman vs. The Elite and that's a crying shame...
-Rob VauxFull Review
Like All-Star Superman before it, SUPERMAN VS. THE ELITE is an exceptional animated superhero movie. It's violent and has some adult subject matter, but it also has a strong, thoughtful story and worthwhile messages.
-Jeffrey M. AndersonFull Review
The conflict between The Elite's way of doing things and Superman's sets up a "might makes right" allegory wrestling with national and global politics as well as, on a more personal level, civilian tolerance of capital punishment. [Blu-ray]
-Peter CanaveseFull Review
A forgettable Superman vehicle and one I won't be re-visiting any time soon.
-Felix Vasquez Jr.Full Review